In CPG, the store has been where shoppers find new products. Walk the aisle, see something new, pick it up. But, this holiday season, the store has company.
According to Sprout Social’s Q3 2026 Pulse Survey, featured in the Nov/Dec issue of Quirk’s, social media is now tied with physical stores as the #1 place shoppers go for gift ideas, at 46% each. For Gen Z, it’s not even close: social ranks first at 54%.
And it’s still growing. 78% of people expect to use social to find gifts as much as or more than they did in 2025, and 28% say they’ll use it more.
So, if that’s where shoppers are discovering products, that’s where your research should be testing them.
Shoppers meet products in the feed and recognize them at the shelf.
It’s easy to read this as a story about two channels competing. It’s really a story about one shopper moving between them.
Shoppers don’t read packaging at shelf. Behavioral scientist Phil Barden estimates shoppers are in visual contact with a given pack for one to three seconds, which is nowhere near enough time to read a claim. It’s not about evaluation, it’s choice by recognition.
That recognition has to be built somewhere first, and increasingly, that somewhere is social feeds.
Decades of research on the exposure effect show that seeing something repeatedly builds familiarity and preference, even when nobody was paying close attention to it. A pack shot that shows up mid-scroll and sticks is doing the work the shelf will cash in on later. The feed is where the memory is made, and the shelf is where it gets retrieved.
Social feeds are a checkout now, too.
Discovery is only half of it.
38% of people have bought something directly inside a social app (think TikTok Shop, Facebook Marketplace or Instagram Checkout) and would do it again. Another 19% say they’d try it for the first time this year.
That’s 57% of people open to going from “never seen it” to “bought it” without leaving the app. Discovery and checkout can now happen in the same scroll, within a few seconds. Which means your claim, your concept, and your message don’t get a second chance down the funnel. They have to break through and convert right then and there.
You’re not competing for preference. You’re competing for attention.
Here’s the part that should make every brand team pause.
When Sprout asked what would make people more likely to buy during the holiday season, promo codes came out on top (30%), followed by posts showing a product in action (28%). Targeted social ads from the brand came in last (18%).
Most brand messages in social feeds get skipped. So, the first question isn’t whether a shopper likes your message. It’s whether anyone stops for it at all. A message can score well in a survey and still be invisible in the feed, because in a survey – unlike a scroll — everyone is already paying attention.
Test in the environment where the decision happens.
But surveys are still where most concepts and claims get tested today.
A panel or a central location test asks people to look at something and focus on it. That’s a reasonable thing to measure, but it isn’t what happens in real life. That’s the gap. In social feeds, your message gets a mere glance between a friend’s vacation photos, a cat video, and another ad –– if it registers at all.
Researchers call this ecological validity: does the test environment look like the real one? If the decision happens in a fast, distracted, low-attention scroll, the test should too. That’s what testing in the wild seeks to find. New product and message ideas are tested as real ads in live social feeds, then we measure what real shoppers actually do: who stops, who clicks and who chooses to buy. It’s the same feed, the same distractions and the same competition for attention your launch will face.
See how we did this with Eggland’s Best, and it resulted in a 31% increase of new buyers.
Keeping it honest:
The Sprout data is a survey. It was conducted online with 2,286 social media users across the US, UK and Australia, so it tells us what people say about how they shop. People who use social media are, unsurprisingly, more likely to say they shop there. But, that doesn’t weaken the point. What people say they’ll do and what they actually do are often two different things, and that gap is exactly why we measure behavior instead of stated intent. The survey tells you where to look. Behavior tells you what’s true.
Why this season raises the stakes
56% of people plan to cut back on holiday spending this year because of economic conditions, and that holds across Gen Z, Millennials, Gen X and Boomers. 69% are worried about price increases from tariffs. Fewer dollars, spent more carefully, means less room for a launch that leads with the wrong message. Getting it wrong costs more than it used to.
What Orchard can do with it
You don’t have to rebuild your research plan to act on this.
Start by moving your earliest, most uncertain decisions into the environment where shoppers are discovering products:
Seed: Find the problem statements, claims and ways-in that actually stop the scroll, before you invest in developing them.
Shape: Pit concepts and positioning against each other in live feeds to see which ones earn clicks and choices, not just compliments.
Activate: Pressure-test launch messaging with real audiences so you go to market with what’s already proven to convert.
Then take your finalists to shelf testing. Final packs, planograms and pricing still need validation close to launch. But by the time you get there, you’ll be testing the ideas that already proved they can earn attention where discovery starts.
Shoppers discover where they scroll. You should be testing where they scroll, too.

